• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • General Ortho
  • Procedures
  • Spine
  • Upper Limb
  • Lower Limb
  • Pain
  • Trauma
  • Tumors
  • Newsletter/Updates
  • About Us
  • Contact Us

Bone and Spine

Orthopedic health, conditions and treatment

Bone Destruction- Patterns and Their Significance

By Dr Arun Pal Singh

In this article
    • Types of Bone Destructions
    • Why do patterns of bone destruction differ?
    • How To Read Bone Destructing Lesion
    • Geographic Bone Destruction
      • Geographic lesions with marginal sclerosis (type IA)
      • Geographic lesions with no sclerosis in the margin (type IB)
      • Geographic lesions with ill-defined margins (type IC)
    • Moth-Eaten Type of Bone Destruction
    • Permeative Bone Destruction
    • Combination of Patterns of Bone Destruction
    • Further Imaging of the Lesions

Different patterns of bone destruction as observed on x-rays are caused by a variety of disease processes affecting the bone. Different types of destructions suggest the intensity and aggression of the disease process.

Classically, x-rays were used for imaging and diagnosis. With the advent of CT and MRI, the x-ray diagnosis of lesions has lost its sheen but these are still the basic investigations to begin with. But it is still important to know and understand the changes on x-rays.

 The destruction patterns of bone we are about to discuss is described on x-ray images.

Types of Bone Destructions

Three radiographic patterns of bone destruction have been identified –

  • Geographic Bone Destruction
  • Moth-eaten Appearance
  • Permeative Bone Destruction

Patterns of Bone destruction are able to provide the information on bony involvement and how aggressively the disease is spreading and how effectively the host bone is able to repair or contain the bony lesion.

Musculoskeletal lesions typically occur within a given age range. Therefore and the age of the patient must be considered when the lesions are evaluated.

Why do patterns of bone destruction differ?

Bone destruction and new bone formation are mediated by osteoclasts and osteoblasts.

Osteoclasts are responsible for eating the bone and osteoblasts for laying new bone. Both the processes and cells continuously work in the body to build, repair, model and remodel the bone.

Therefore, bony destruction seen on radiographs is a summation of osteoclasts resorptive activity on both the cortical and trabecular bone surfaces. The relative predominance of bone process over the other will be perceived as a visible margin to the lesion on the radiograph.

Destruction of cortical bone although slower is appreciated more easily because of the great contrast in density created by a local area of lysis as compared to the cancellous bone where a large amount of trabecular bone must be removed before the loss will be evident on plain radiographs.

For this reason, lesions arising in the cancellous bone may go undetected for long periods of time.

How To Read Bone Destructing Lesion

In order to reach a consistent grading conclusion, the following specific sign must be considered in this order of priority:

  1. The pattern of bone destruction
  2. the configuration of the marginal interface zone of the lesion.
  3. Penetration of bone cortex by the lesion.
  4. Presence or absence of a sclerotic rim.
  5. Presence and extent of an expanded cortical shell.
Different Types of Bone Destruction
Different Types of Bone Destruction

Geographic Bone Destruction

The geographic pattern of bone destruction is the least aggressive pattern of bone destruction and is generally indicative of a slowly growing lesion. The margin of the lesion is well-defined and easily separated from the surrounding normal bone.

This margin may be smooth or irregular, but in either instance, it is usually clearly demarcated, with a short zone of transition from normal to abnormal bone.

In some instance, a sclerotic margin of variable thickness surrounds the lesion. The thicker and more complete the sclerotic margin, the less aggressive the process.

This type of destruction is seen as a well-circumscribed hole in the bone with a narrow zone transition between normal and abnormal bone. The pattern implies a slow growth rate, one that permits time for destruction of all bone in the path of the enlarging lesion. The geographic destruction patterns can be further divided into three subtypes.

  • A—Geographic lesions with sclerotic margin:
  • B—Geographic lesions without sclerotic margins:
  • C—Geographic lesions with ill-defined margins.

The relative biological aggressiveness increases from type A to type C.

Geographic lesions with marginal sclerosis (type IA)

The lesions have a sclerotic rim around the destruction.

This pattern is most commonly associated with benign, slow-growing disorders. Lesions commonly falling into this category are

  • Unicameral bone cyst
  • Nonossifying fibroma
  • Enchondroma
  • Chondromyxoid fibroma
  • Chondroblastoma
  • Fibrous dysplasia

Some lesions have sclerotic rims that gradually fade into the adjacent cancellous bone are commonly seen with

  • Chronic osteomyelitis
  • Brodie’s abscess
  • Histiocytosis X.

Geographic lesions with no sclerosis in the margin (type IB)

These lesions have sharply defined edges but not sclerotic margins.

Normal trabeculae are present up to the edge of the lesion. But the trabeculae are removed along a plane of contact between the tumor and normal bone.

The lesions mentioned in IA category may also fall into this category when they demonstrate more aggressive behavior.

Giant cell tumors typically have IB margins.

Geographic lesions with ill-defined margins (type IC)

In this type of geographic lesion, there is focal destruction present but there is also spread of the disease beyond  is  the visible lytic lesion. This creates a wider zone of transition at the margin of the lesion which reflects the greater biological activity.

he lesion is less well-defined.

In these lesions, vigorous destruction of the cortex will result in complete perforation of the bone.

A soft tissue mass when present, indicates complete cortical penetration.

Typical lesions with this pattern include

  • Giant cell tumor
  • Fibrosarcoma
  • Chondrosarcoma
  • Aggressive forms of
    • Enchondroma
    • Chondroblastoma
    • Desmoplastic fibroma

Moth-Eaten Type of Bone Destruction

The moth-eaten pattern is a more aggressive pattern of bone destruction and is characteristic of a lesion that is growing more rapidly than one that demonstrates geographic bone destruction.

The moth-eaten pattern is associated with a less well-defined or demarcated lesion margin and with a longer zone of transition from normal to abnormal bone.

The moth-eaten appearance of the bone consists of multiple scattered holes that vary in size and seem to arise separately. These scattered holes coalesce to form larger areas of bone destruction.

In cancellous bone, normal trabecular markings can be seen between the holes because of the regionally infiltrative nature of this pattern.

Total penetration of the cortex is assumed with the moth-eaten pattern.

The moth-eaten pattern is frequently seen in malignant neoplasms such as

  • Ewing’s sarcoma
  • Primary lymphoma of bone
  • Chondrosarcoma
  • Fibrosarcoma
  • Osteosarcoma
  • An aggressive form of osteomyelitis

Some benign processes, such as eosinophilic granuloma, may be associated with moth-eaten destruction.

Permeative Bone Destruction

The permeative pattern indicates an aggressive bone lesion with rapid growth potential. The lesion is poorly demarcated and not easily separated from the surrounding normal bone. In fact, it may imperceptibly merge with uninvolved osseous segments and create a zone of transition that is very long.

Its true size is larger than that evident on radiographs.

The permeative pattern is characterized by numerous elongated holes or slots in the cortex that run parallel to the long axis of the bone. They are reasonably uniform in size. The slots are created by osteoclastic cortical tunneling in an accelerated caricature of the resorption phase of normal Haversian remodeling. Total penetration of the cortex is assumed with the permeative pattern.

Permeative destruction may be seen in several disease categories including neoplastic, mechanical inflammatory, and metabolic.

Tunneling may or maybe not be accompanied by tumor or inflammatory infiltrates.

Malignant lesion demonstrating this pattern tends to infiltrate the marrow space diffusely and include primary round cell tumors, fibrosarcoma, high-grade chondrosarcoma, and angiosarcoma.

An occasional benign process such osteomyelitis will also show this pattern.

The pattern may be often difficult to differentiate from the permeative patterns of destruction.

Combination of Patterns of Bone Destruction

Any combination of geographic, ‘moth-eaten’, and permeative patterns in a single lesion is indicative of a change towards a more aggressive local growth.

Combination patterns may be seen when benign lesions become more active, undergo malignant degeneration, or fracture. The development of a combination or a changing pattern can be documented by observing a sequence of radiographs.

Further Imaging of the Lesions

Further workup, wherever required consists of MRI and/or CT

While CT is very good for bony evaluation of the lesion, MRI will also aid in establishing which compartments and structures are involved.

A nuclear medicine bone scan is performed to look for multiple bone involvement.

If the lesion is still nonspecific after thorough imaging, an image-guided biopsy of the lesion can be performed.

Save

Save

Save

Save

Save

Save

Save

Save

Save

Save

Spread the Knowledge
  • 6
    Shares
  •  
    6
    Shares
  • 1
  • 5
  •  
  •  
  •  

Filed Under: General Ortho

About Dr Arun Pal Singh

Arun Pal Singh is an orthopedic and trauma surgeon, founder and chief editor of this website. He works in Kanwar Bone and Spine Clinic, Dasuya, Hoshiarpur, Punjab.

This website is an effort to educate and support people and medical personnel on orthopedic issues and musculoskeletal health.

You can follow him on Facebook, Linkedin and Twitter

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Truong Ba Ngac says

    March 12, 2008 at 6:54 pm

    I would like having more information about geographic bone destruction because my patient has a X-ray film like that

  2. Dr Arun Pal Singh says

    March 12, 2008 at 3:02 pm

    I would be able to help you if you let me know what exactly you need to know. I think geographic destruction is covered well in the present article.

    However, if you want to diagnose the patient of yours you need to investigate him further.

    We are soon starting a column on advice. But if you wish you could send me an email at “contact at boneandspine dot com”.

  3. julie windsor says

    November 13, 2009 at 7:16 pm

    can a permative pattern in the bone be directly linked to myelodysplatic syndromes?

  4. Dr Arun Pal Singh says

    November 16, 2009 at 6:14 pm

    @julie windsor,

    It might be one of the reasons but the diagnosis can not be made on this basis only.
    There are plenty of other causes that can cause permeative destruction.

    One needs to see whole profile of the patient including other investigations.

  5. Rehan Arain says

    April 12, 2016 at 8:04 pm

    I want to Ask that is there any relation between the calcification and the other disease osteopenia??? as both are related to the low bone density?????

  6. Dr Arun Pal Singh says

    April 16, 2016 at 10:22 am

    Rehan,

    Would you please elaborate that further?

Primary Sidebar

muckle wells syndrome

Muckle Wells Syndrome

Muckle-Wells syndrome [Also known by the names of  UDA (Urticaria Deafness Amyloidosis) syndrome   is a rare autosomal dominant disease which results in Sensorineural deafness Recurrent hives Amyloidosis – A disease where abnormal deposition of amyloid occurs in various organs. Fevers Painful joints (arthritis) Muckle-Wells syndrome was first described in 1962 by Thomas James Muckle and […]

Axillary nerve injury would affect its supply as shown

Axillary Nerve Injury – Causes, Effects and Treatment

Axillary nerve injury can result either from compression of the axillary nerve or traumatic injury resulting from traction, direct trauma or from injections. As deltoid is the muscle that is being supplied along with skin over the deltoid area, the axillary nerve injury causes deltoid muscle paralysis and numbness over the region. Axillary nerve injury is […]

Enneking staging system for benign tumors

Enneking Staging System and TGNM Staging System for Musculoskeletal Tumors

Enneking Staging System and TGNM staging system are two main staging systems used for staging for benign and malignant tumors of the musculoskeletal system Many factors are involved in choosing the proper therapy for the patients. They include the stage of the disease, the expected functional result after surgery, the age of the patient, the […]

Discography in Lateral position Image

Lumbar Discography – Indications, Procedure and Inference

Lumbar discography is an invasive diagnostic procedure that involves, instillation of iodinated contrast into the nucleus pulposus after inserting a needle under fluoroscopy. This procedure is done with an aim to get information on the morphology and integrity nucleus pulposus, vertebral endplates and annulus fibrosus. In addition to this, the measured contrast injection allows determination […]

Dysplasia Spondyloepophysealis Congenita

Dysplasia Spondyloepophysealis Congenita

Dysplasia spondyloepophysealis congenita is characterized by a short-trunk type of dwarfism with the involvement of the spine and limb epiphyses, particularly the proximal ones. The radiological changes can be identified at birth, though the child may not always be diagnosed clinically at birth. Clinical Features of Dysplasia Spondyloepophysealis Congenita Dwarfism is present both in the […]

Grade IV KL OA

Knee Osteoarthritis Symptoms and Treatment

This article focuses on Knee Osteoarthritis. For details on Osteoarthritis, read Osteoarthritis Symptoms, Diagnosis and Treatment Knee osteoarthritis is can result in severe pain and disability, and affect activities like walking even for short distances or climbing stairs. Like all other osteoarthritides, knee osteoarthritis takes a quite some time to develop and worsens gradually. Earlier […]

RICE therapy

RICE Therapy – Rest, Ice, Compression, Elevation

RICE stands for Rest, Ice, Compression and Elevation. These four indicates measures taken in the acute setting of injury. The purpose of RICE therapy is to reduce pain, bleeding and ultimately swelling. Too much swelling interferes with healing [Body has to work to reduce swelling in addition to the original healing process], can lead to […]

Browse Articles

Footer

Pages

  • About
    • Policies
    • Contact Us

Featured Article

Thoracolumbar Spine Injuries Presentation and Treatment

Thoracolumbar spine injuries refer to injuries of the thoracic and lumbar spine. Thoracic spine has 12 vertebrae from T1 to T12 whereas lumbar … [Read More...] about Thoracolumbar Spine Injuries Presentation and Treatment

Search Articles

© Copyright: BoneAndSpine.com